Would You Rather . . . : Impromptu Speaking with a Twist

Would You Rather board gameThough I’ve taught public speaking for years, I’ve never been quite comfortable with the exercises I’ve found for impromptu speaking, until now.

One approach I’ve seen many professors use is having the students write topics on little slips of paper, and then having the students draw one of the topics. Give the student a few moments to prepare, and then have the student get up and speak. The plus side of this is that it doesn’t require much work for the professor. The down side is that some students draw topics they have little or no knowledge about, which puts them at a real disadvantage over the students who are familiar with the topics they draw.

This semester, I took a new approach. I brought a board game to class with me, and we played Would You Rather . . .? together. On each card in the game, you’ll find four categories, each with one question. The questions are fun and thought-provoking. Below is a copy of one of the cards.

Would You Rather card

For our first and second round of impromptus, I had each person draw a card and choose which question he or she wanted to answer. I encouraged them to use the PRSR (say it like “pressure”) format, where they first state their point, offer their reason, provide support, then finally restate their main point. I went first for each round so they could hear what I was looking for.

For the final round, student could choose the category (orange, blue, green, or yellow), and a classmate would read a question to them. They had so much fun with this, we took turns going through the box and answering questions after we were “done.”

Additionally, before we even played Would You Rather . . .?, I helped them to relax a bit by watching some video clips of impromptu speeches. Well, sort of. We watched a few clips from Whose Line is it Anyway, focusing mostly on the Scenes from a Hat segments.


NOTE: Earlier in the semester, I showed them Miss Teen South Carolina’s answer to why some Americans cannot find America on a map. (This was a classic example of now NOT to do an impromptu speech.)


4 responses to “Would You Rather . . . : Impromptu Speaking with a Twist

  1. I think it sounds like great fun and a much better alternative to speaking on an unknown topic.

    In the land of asking impromptu questions, when getting to know someone I always ask them to tell me the story of their proudest moment. It is not only revealing but also a great way for people to get in their element.

    I’m not sure if that would be too personal for a classroom setting, but perhaps it could be adapted in someway.

  2. Lindsey

    Your “proudest moment” idea is similar to my “personal best” speech that students give early in the semester. They can talk about any time in their life that they felt, at least for a moment or two, that they were at their best. It’s a great way for them to let us into a part of their lives (of their choosing) that we probably wouldn’t know about otherwise).


  3. I love this idea, and I will probably borrow it at some point! Thanks for sharing.

  4. Robyn McFarland

    I love your idea! I’ve just ordered this game and I can’t wait to use it with my students. I’m always looking for fun ideas to spice up my class.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s